Cat Kibble Chart
This information is for cats.
If you have ferrets, please check out Ferret Love
If you have ferrets, please check out Ferret Love
Last updated: (7 months ago)
Create an account to hide ads!
Kibble can generally be left out for days without spoiling. However, it needs something (usually a grain) to bind all of the ingredients together to form its solid shape. Therefore most kibbles are high in fruit, veggie, and/or grain content, which is not great for cats.
Notice how raw diets clearly advertise their meat percentage ("96% meat, organs, and bone" on Ziwipeak for example) but kibbles do not. They hide this information, which is why I don't have it for most of these foods yet.
Kibble Brands
Note: the average score is for each brand's kibbles only. They may offer other types that score higher or lower.
All Kibbles
| Analysis | Ingredients | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name | Score | Meat | Protein | Fat | grain- & starch- free |
1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | |
| B | 86% | 40% | 17.5% | herring | mackerel | whitefish | catfish meal | whitefish meal | |||
| B | - | 40% | 20% | deboned beef | deboned wild boar | deboned goat | deboned lamb | lamb liver | |||
| B | - | 56% | 17% | salmon | dried chicken | dried egg product | gelatin | salmon hydrolysate | |||
| B | 90% | 52% | 22% | dried chicken meat | chicken | chicken fat | sweet potato | potato | |||
| B | - | 36% | 18% | deboned chicken | deboned turkey | chicken liver | chicken meal | catfish meal | |||
| B | 80% | 39% | 18% | chicken | dried rabbit | dried duck | chicken fat | pumpkin | |||
| B | - | 40% | 23.5% | duck | turkey meal | chicken meal | chicken fat | white fish meal | |||
| B | 82% | 41% | 24% | chicken | chicken meal | turkey meal | menhaden fish meal | chicken fat | |||
| B | - | 42% | 20% | lamb | dehydrated lamb | sweet potatoes | chicken fat | dried whole eggs | |||
| B | - | 40.5% | 22.5% | rabbit | turkey meal | menhaden fish meal | chicken fat | white fish meal | |||
| B | 75% | 36% | 20% | dehydrated chicken | freshly prepared chicken | rice | chicken fat | prepared salmon | |||
| B | - | 44% | 20% | wild boar | dehydrated wild boar | sweet potatoes | boneless chicken | dehydrated chicken | |||
| B | - | 59% | 18% | chicken | dried egg product | pork protein concentrate | gelatin | chicken fat | |||
| B | - | 36% | 18% | deboned duck | deboned chicken | eggs | chicken meal | turkey meal | |||
| B | 77% | 38% | 21% | dehydrated chicken | freshly prepared chicken | rice | chicken fat | chicken liver | |||
| B | - | 38% | 18% | deboned pork | deboned beef | beef liver | pork liver | deboned lamb | |||
| B | 80% | 46% | 16% | chicken | turkey | duck | guinea fowl | potatoes | |||
| B | - | 50% | 22% | hydrolyzed pork | chicken meal | chicken fat | potato starch | chicken liver flavor | |||
| B | - | 41% | 22% | chicken | chicken meal | turkey meal | menhaden fish meal | peas | |||
| B | 75% | 36% | 21% | dehydrated chicken | freshly prepared chicken | rice | chicken fat | chicken liver | |||
| B | - | 42.5% | 22.5% | chicken | turkey meal | menhaden fish meal | peas | chicken fat | |||
| B | - | 45% | 18% | deboned turkey | deboned chicken | turkey meal | chicken meal | peas | |||
| B | - | 41% | 21% | chicken | chicken meal | turkey meal | menhaden fish meal | peas | |||
| B | - | 43% | 19% | deboned chicken | chicken meal | dehydrated chicken | dried egg product | tapioca | |||
| B | - | 40% | 12% | dehydrated chicken | dehydrated deboned chicken | chicken | turkey | chicken liver | |||
| B | - | 40% | 12% | salmon | dehydrated deboned chicken | dehydrated chicken | whitefish | turkey | |||
| B | - | 40% | 20% | deboned beef | deboned lamb | deboned wild boar | beef liver | lamb liver | |||
SquarePet HMLC Turkey & Chicken Formula
Discontinued
|
B | - | 48% | 20% | turkey | chicken | turkey meal | chicken meal | salmon meal | ||
| B | - | 42% | 18.5% | salmon | menhaden fish meal | white fish meal | pacific whiting | pacific sole | |||
| B | 70% | 44% | 20% | boneless chicken meat | dried chicken meat | potatoes | chicken fat | dried egg | |||
| B | - | 45% | 18% | deboned turkey | turkey meal | deboned chicken | chicken meal | peas | |||
| B | - | 37% | 21% | dried chicken | dried turkey | maize | pork fat | chicken | |||
| B | - | 44% | 20% | boneless chicken | dehydrated chicken | sweet potatoes | chicken fat | dried whole eggs | |||
| B | - | 36% | 18% | whole mackerel | whole herring | whole hake | acadian redfish | mackerel meal | |||
| B | - | 54% | 26% | hydrolyzed pork | chicken meal | chicken fat | chicken liver flavor | guar gum | |||
| B | - | 40% | 23% | duck | turkey meal | chicken meal | chicken fat | white fish meal | |||
| B | - | 40% | 20% | deboned goat | deboned wild boar | whole arctic char | deboned venison | steelhead trout | |||
| B | 86% | 40% | 20% | turkey | chicken | duck | duck meal | turkey meal | |||
| B | - | 47.3% | 19.5% | chicken meal | de-boned chicken | chicken fat | de-boned turkey | turkey meal | |||
| B | - | 42% | 20% | deboned chicken | deboned turkey | chicken meal | turkey meal | salmon | |||
| B | - | 37% | 18% | chicken meat | turkey meat | chicken liver | dehydrated chicken meat | dehydrated turkey meat | |||
| B | - | 38% | 18% | salmon | pollock | cod | haddock | flounder | |||
| B | - | 40% | 20% | chicken meat | turkey meat | whole eggs | chicken liver | whole flounder | |||
| B | - | 40% | 20% | whole atlantic mackerel | whole atlantic herring | flounder | whole acadian redfish | atlantic monkfish | |||
| B | - | 40% | 20% | deboned chicken | chicken meal | turkey meal | deboned cod | whole peas | |||
| B | 80% | 34% | 14% | carp | dried trout | hydrolyzed salmon | dried salmon | pumpkin | |||
| B | 86% | 39% | 19% | lamb | pork | lamb meal | mutton meal | pork meal | |||
| B | - | 37% | 18% | humanely raised turkey | humanely raised chicken | ocean whitefish meal | herring meal | garbanzo beans | |||
| B | - | 47% | 17% | duck | chicken | chicken eggs | tapioca | ground flaxseed | |||
| C | - | 40% | 18% | deboned chicken | deboned turkey | chicken meal | turkey meal | pea protein | |||
| C | - | 40% | 18% | deboned turkey | turkey meal | menhaden fish meal | deboned cod | yellow peas | |||
| C | 82% | 37% | 20% | dry chicken meal | dry salmon | chicken mince | potato | salmon | |||
| C | 75% | 40% | 18% | duck meat | pheasant meat | yellow peas | chicken fat | beet pulp | |||
| C | 75% | 40% | 20% | salmon meal | turkey meal | yellow peas | chicken fat | chicken protein hydrolyzed | |||
| C | - | 40% | 20% | deboned chicken | chicken meal | pea protein | tapioca starch | menhaden fish meal | |||
| C | - | 38% | 18% | chicken | chicken byproduct meal | corn grits | ground whole grain corn | salmon | |||
| C | - | 33% | 19% | chicken | chicken liver | dried egg product | dried peas | soy protein concentrate | |||
| C | - | 47% | 17% | chicken | tapioca | chicken fat | ground flaxseed | natural flavor | |||
| C | 80% | 37% | 17% | dry chicken | dry lamb | dry potato | chicken mince | beet pulp | |||
| C | - | 40% | 18% | turkey | chicken meal | potato | duck meal | peas | |||
| C | - | 36% | 20% | chicken | chicken meal | turkey meal | brown rice | cracked pearled barley | |||
| C | - | 36% | 16% | duck | duck meal | turkey meal | chicken meal | sweet potatoes | |||
| C | - | 42% | 15% | deboned chicken | chicken meal | turkey meal | potatoes | peas | |||
| C | - | 39% | 15.5% | chicken | chicken meal | lentils | peas | chicken fat | |||
| C | - | 36% | 16% | chicken | chicken meal | brown rice | white rice | chicken fat | |||
| C | - | 42% | 19% | chicken | pea protein | chicken meal | cassava root flour | dried egg product | |||
| C | - | 38% | 16% | chicken | chicken meal | lentils | peas | chicken fat | |||
| C | - | 33% | 19% | salmon | whitefish | dried egg product | dried peas | tapioca | |||
| C | - | 38% | 18% | deboned chicken | chicken meal | yellow peas | green lentils | chicken fat | |||
| C | 70% | 37% | 18% | duck meal | turkey meal | yellow peas | chicken fat | apples | |||
| C | 84% | 37% | 20% | dry chicken meal | dry duck meal | freshly prepared chicken mince | potato | beet pulp | |||
| C | - | 33% | 16% | deboned chicken | chicken meal | turkey meal | oatmeal | whole peas | |||
| C | - | 42% | 19% | chicken | corn gluten meal | rice | beef fat | soybean meal | |||
| C | - | 34% | 18% | chicken | chicken meal | turkey meal | brown rice | peas | |||
| C | - | 33% | 21% | chicken | chicken by-product meal | ground whole grain corn | ground sorghum | chicken fat | |||
| C | - | 38% | 20% | dried chicken meat meal | chicken mince | potatoes | yeast | beet pulp | |||
| C | - | 30% | 20% | chicken | chicken meal | whole grain brown rice | ground white rice | chicken fat | |||
| C | - | 40% | 15% | chicken | chicken by-product meal | corn gluten meal | soy flour | ground yellow corn | |||
| D | - | 40% | 18% | deboned chicken | chicken meal | pea protein | tapioca starch | peas | |||
| D | - | 40% | 18% | deboned duck | chicken meal | pea protein | peas | tapioca starch | |||
| D | - | 40% | 18% | turkey meal | chicken meal | peas | chicken fat | pea starch | |||
| D | - | 33% | 16% | chicken breast | chicken meal | peas | lentils | chicken fat | |||
| D | - | 32% | 16% | whitefish | whitefish meal | peas | lentils | chicken fat | |||
| D | - | 30% | 14% | chicken | chicken meal | oat | milo | millet | |||
| D | - | 33% | 15% | turkey | lentils | sunflower oil | natural flavor | salmon oil | |||
| D | - | 35.5% | 16.5% | turkey meal | peas | turkey | tapioca | canola oil | |||
| D | - | 42% | 18% | chicken meal | peas | sweet potatoes | chicken fat | pea protein | |||
| D | - | 34% | 16% | chicken meal | lentils | field peas | chicken fat | chickpeas | |||
| D | - | 32% | 16% | trout | ocean fish meal | sweet potatoes | potatoes | pea protein | |||
| D | 50% | 34% | 15% | white fish | peas | herring meal | chickpea flour | lentils | |||
| D | - | 30% | 14% | turkey | herring meal | oats | milo | millet | |||
| D | - | 30% | 14% | salmon | catfish meal | oat | millet | sunflower oil | |||
| D | - | 35% | 14% | salmon | ocean fish meal | lentils | chickpeas | peas | |||
| D | - | 33.8% | 15.7% | chicken | whole grain corn | corn gluten meal | whole grain wheat | brewers rice | |||
| D | - | 40% | 18% | salmon meal | pacific whiting meal | peas | pea protein | pea starch | |||
| D | - | 35% | 17% | chicken by-product meal | brewers rice | corn gluten meal | whole grain corn | powdered cellulose | |||
| D | - | 30% | 15% | beef | lentils | sunflower oil | natural flavor | salmon oil | |||
| D | - | 32% | 15% | chicken | chicken meal | peas | faba beans | pea protein | |||
| D | - | 32% | 15% | salmon | menhaden fish meal | peas | lentils | pea protein | |||
| D | - | 34% | 17% | rice | poultry by-product meal | corn gluten meal | beef fat | whole grain corn | |||
| D | - | 35% | 13% | chicken | pea protein | red lentils | buckwheat | natural flavors | |||
| D | - | 34.5% | 21.3% | yellow peas | pea protein | duck | green peas | pork fat | |||
| F | - | 36% | 15% | chicken by-product meal | brewers rice | corn gluten meal | whole ground corn | soybean meal | |||
| F | - | 36% | 14% | chicken meal | ground brown rice | pea protein | oat meal | dried egg product | |||
| F | - | 32% | 13% | black soldier fly larvae | hydrolyzed yeast protein | herring meal | millet | peas | |||
| F | - | 32% | 13% | black soldier fly larvae | hydrolyzed yeast protein | millet | peas | lentils | |||
| F | - | 30% | 10.5% | ground yellow corn | chicken by-product meal | corn gluten meal | soybean meal | ground wheat | |||
| F | - | 30% | 9% | ground yellow corn | corn gluten meal | chicken by-product meal | soybean meal | beef tallow | |||
| F | 0% | 30% | 14% | whole grain oatmeal | high protein maize gluten meal | high protein soybean meal | pea protein | potato flakes | |||
| F | 0% | 30% | 16% | organic sunflower meal | organic peas | organic soybeans | organic soybean meal | organic soybean oil | |||
