		Analysis			Ingredients
Name	Score	Meat	Protein	Fat	grain- & starch- free	1st	2nd	3rd	4th	5th
Smalls Water Bird Recipe Discontinued	A+	98%	45%	20%		finely ground duck with bone	duck heart	duck liver	duck gizzard	duck egg
Smalls Other Bird Recipe Discontinued	A+	98%	49%	17%		finely ground turkey with bone	turkey heart	turkey liver	turkey gizzard	goat's milk
Northwest Naturals Freeze-Dried Cat Nibbles Turkey Recipe	A+	98%	45%	15%		turkey	turkey neck	turkey hearts	turkey liver	egg
Vital Essentials Duck Dinner Patties	A+	94%	47%	21%		duck	duck gizzard	duck heart	duck liver	herring oil
Stella & Chewy's Duck Duck Goose	A+	98%	40%	30%		duck with ground bone	turkey with ground bone	turkey liver	goose	turkey gizzard
Nulo FreeStyle Turkey & Duck	A+	98%	42%	37%		turkey	turkey necks	turkey liver	duck	duck liver
Vital Essentials Turkey Dinner Patties	A+	94%	53%	20%		turkey	turkey heart	turkey liver	herring oil	mixed tocopherols
Feline Natural Lamb & King Salmon Feast	A+	99%	44%	37%		lamb heart	salmon	lamb kidney	lamb liver	lamb blood
Northwest Naturals Freeze-Dried Cat Nibbles Duck Recipe	A+	98%	35%	30%		duck with bone	duck heart	duck liver	egg	gelatin
Steve's Real Food Quest Cat Food Whitefish	A+	95%	55%	18%		pollock	pacific cod	rockfish	salmon	chia seed
Feline Natural Beef & Hoki Feast	A+	99%	47%	32%		beef heart	hoki	beef	beef kidney	beef liver
Northwest Naturals Freeze-Dried Cat Nibbles Rabbit Recipe	A+	98%	45%	15%		rabbit with bone	rabbit heart	rabbit liver	gelatin	water
Northwest Naturals Freeze-Dried Cat Nibbles Beef & Trout Recipe	A+	98%	33%	45%		beef heart	trout with ground bone	ground beef bone	beef	beef liver
Open Farm Surf & Turf Freeze Dried Raw Cat Food	A+	98%	45%	34%		salmon	beef	beef liver	beef heart	beef bone
Stella & Chewy's Tummy Ticklin’ Turkey	A+	98%	40%	37%		turkey with ground bone	turkey liver	turkey gizzard	pumpkin seed	potassium chloride
Nature's Variety Instinct Raw Meals Wild-Caught Alaskan Pollock Recipe	A+	95%	44%	32%		pollock	beef	beef spleen	beef liver	beef kidney
Northwest Naturals Freeze-Dried Cat Nibbles Whitefish Recipe	A+	98%	50%	9%		whitefish	whitefish with bone	egg	gelatin	water
Steve's Real Food Quest Cat Food Pork	A+	95%	49%	29%		ground pork	pork liver	pork heart	ground pork bone	goat milk
Steve's Real Food Quest Cat Food Beef	A+	95%	46%	37%		ground beef	beef hearts	beef kidney	beef liver	raw goat’s milk
Open Farm Wild-Caught Salmon & Cod Freeze Dried Raw Cat Food	A+	92%	41%	25%		salmon with ground bone	cod	sweet potato	montmorillonite clay	fenugreek seeds
Stella & Chewy's Absolutely Rabbit	A	98%	44%	30%		rabbit with ground bone	rabbit liver	olive oil	pumpkin seed	potassium chloride

Dark Green	Pure meat source (1st - 5th ingredient)
Light Green	Pure meat source (6th ingredient +)
Green Outline	Meat by-product
Orange	Fruit / Grain / Vegetable / Dairy (1st - 5th ingredient)
Orange Outline	Fruit / Grain / Vegetable / Dairy (oil or 6th ingredient +)
Red	Sugar
Blue Outline	Vitamin / Mineral / Amino Acid / Probiotic
Blue Dashed Outline	Preservative / Coloring

		Analysis			Ingredients
Name	Score	Meat	Protein	Fat	grain- & starch- free	1st	2nd	3rd	4th	5th
Venandi Ente als Monoprotein	A+	99%	11%	6%		duck	meat	heart	liver	meat broth
ZiwiPeak Wet East Cape Recipe Discontinued	A+	97%	10.5%	8.5%		mutton	lamb broth	goat	whole kahawai	goat tripe
ZiwiPeak Wet Otago Valley Recipe Discontinued	A+	97%	9%	7%		beef	beef broth	venison	whole southern blue whiting	lamb tripe
Venandi Kalb als Monoprotein	A+	99%	11%	5.5%		veal	lung	heart	kidney	spleen
Rawz Turkey & Turkey Liver Pate	A+	96%	12%	9.5%		turkey	turkey liver	turkey broth	potassium chloride	fenugreek seeds
ZiwiPeak Wet Mackerel & Lamb Recipe	A+	92%	10.5%	4%		mackerel	water	lamb	lamb lung	chickpeas
ZiwiPeak Wet Lamb Recipe	A+	92%	9.5%	6%		lamb	water	lamb lung	lamb kidney	lamb liver
Tiki Cat After Dark Beef & Beef Liver Paté	A+	95%	11%	8%		beef	water	beef liver	beef lung	beef kidney
Wysong Epigen Canned Salmon	A	95%	10%	7%		salmon	water	natural flavor	organic guar gum	mixed tocopherols
Wysong Epigen Canned Turkey	A	95%	10%	8%		turkey	water	natural flavor	organic guar gum	mixed tocopherols
Wysong Epigen Canned Rabbit	A	95%	10%	8%		rabbit	water	natural flavor	organic guar gum	mixed tocopherols
Wysong Epigen Canned Duck	A	95%	10%	8%		duck	water	natural flavor	organic guar gum	mixed tocopherols
Inception Fish Recipe	A	-	10.5%	7%		trout	salmon	whitefish	fish broth	catfish
Natures Menu Country Hunter Turkey and Rabbit Discontinued	A	96%	10.6%	6.4%		turkey	rabbit	blackcurrant	cranberry	spirulina
Koha Limited Ingredient Turkey Pâté	A	96%	10%	8%		turkey	water	turkey liver	ground flaxseed	pumpkin
Natures Menu Country Hunter Duck and Pheasant Discontinued	A	96%	10.5%	6.3%		duck	pheasant	blueberry	cranberry	spirulina
Tiki Cat After Dark Venison & Beef Liver Paté	A	95%	13%	3%		venison	water	beef liver	dried yeast	cassia gum
Koha Limited Ingredient Rabbit Au Jus	A	96%	9%	4%		rabbit	water	ground flaxseed	new zealand green mussel	agar agar
Koha Limited Ingredient Duck Pâté	B	96%	8%	8%		duck	water	ground flaxseed	pumpkin	new zealand green mussel
Inception Poultry Recipe	B	-	10%	7%		turkey	duck broth	guineafowl	quail	duck
Inception Red Meat Recipe	B	-	10%	7%		lamb	pork	lamb broth	pork liver	boar
Taste of the Wild Canyon River Feline Recipe	C	-	8%	3%		trout	fish broth	vegetable broth	ocean fish	salmon

		Analysis			Ingredients
Name	Score	Meat	Protein	Fat	grain- & starch- free	1st	2nd	3rd	4th	5th
Essence Ocean & Freshwater	B	86%	40%	17.5%		herring	mackerel	whitefish	catfish meal	whitefish meal
Orijen Regional Red	B	-	40%	20%		deboned beef	deboned wild boar	deboned goat	deboned lamb	lamb liver
Catit Recipes Oak Valley	B	-	38%	18%		deboned pork	deboned beef	beef liver	pork liver	deboned lamb
Nutrience SubZero Prairie Red	B	-	40%	20%		deboned beef	deboned lamb	deboned wild boar	beef liver	lamb liver
Nature's Variety Instinct Raw Boost Grain-Free Salmon	B	-	42%	18.5%		salmon	menhaden fish meal	white fish meal	pacific whiting	pacific sole
Acana Wild Atlantic	B	-	36%	18%		whole mackerel	whole herring	whole hake	acadian redfish	mackerel meal
Orijen Tundra	B	-	40%	20%		deboned goat	deboned wild boar	whole arctic char	deboned venison	steelhead trout
Catit Recipes Pacific Bay	B	-	38%	18%		salmon	pollock	cod	haddock	flounder
Orijen Six Fish	B	-	40%	20%		whole atlantic mackerel	whole atlantic herring	flounder	whole acadian redfish	atlantic monkfish
Essence Ranch & Meadow	B	86%	39%	19%		lamb	pork	lamb meal	mutton meal	pork meal

Taste of the Wild Turkey Limited Ingredient Recipe	D	-	33%	15%		turkey	lentils	sunflower oil	natural flavor	salmon oil
Nature's Variety Instinct Limited Ingredient Diet Grain-Free Turkey	D	-	35.5%	16.5%		turkey meal	peas	turkey	tapioca	canola oil
Taste of the Wild Canyon River Feline Recipe	D	-	32%	16%		trout	ocean fish meal	sweet potatoes	potatoes	pea protein
Applaws Complete Dry Adult Cat Ocean Fish with Salmon	D	50%	34%	15%		white fish	peas	herring meal	chickpea flour	lentils
Inception Turkey & Herring Meal Recipe	D	-	30%	14%		turkey	herring meal	oats	milo	millet
Inception Fish Recipe	D	-	30%	14%		salmon	catfish meal	oat	millet	sunflower oil
Stella & Chewy's Raw Coated Salmon Kibble	D	-	35%	14%		salmon	ocean fish meal	lentils	chickpeas	peas
Earthborn Holistic Wild Sea Catch	D	-	40%	18%		salmon meal	pacific whiting meal	peas	pea protein	pea starch
Chicken Soup Grain-Free Salmon & Legumes	D	-	32%	15%		salmon	menhaden fish meal	peas	lentils	pea protein
Taste of the Wild Angus Beef Limited Ingredient Recipe	D	-	30%	15%		beef	lentils	sunflower oil	natural flavor	salmon oil
Hill's Prescription Diet d/d Feline Duck & Green Pea Formula	D	-	34.5%	21.3%		yellow peas	pea protein	duck	green peas	pork fat
Catit Nuna Insect Protein & Herring	F	-	32%	13%		black soldier fly larvae	hydrolyzed yeast protein	herring meal	millet	peas

Cat Food-Sensitive Diet Chart

Freeze-Dried Raw

Frozen Raw

Air-Dried Raw

Canned

Kibble

Treats

Steam & Dried Raw