Carnilove Duck & Turkey vs. Dr. Elsey's cleanprotein Duck & Chicken

cat
This information is for cats.
If you have ferrets, please check out Ferret Love

Create an account to hide ads!

vs

Carnilove has a better protein to fat ratio. Dr. Elsey's's ratio of 3.22 to 1 is too high (not fatty enough). (The ideal ratio is 2 to 1.) Dr. Elsey's has fewer ingredients, which is usually a good thing. Dr. Elsey's has a slightly lower concentration of fruits, veggies, grains, and starches.

Carnilove Duck & Turkey

Carnilove has a better protein to fat ratio. Dr. Elsey's's ratio of 3.22 to 1 is too high (not fatty enough). (The ideal ratio is 2 to 1.)

Legend

First 10 ingredients:

duck meal turkey meal yellow peas chicken fat apples duck deboned tapioca starch chicken liver salmon oil carrots

Dr. Elsey's cleanprotein Duck & Chicken

Dr. Elsey's has fewer ingredients, which is usually a good thing.
Dr. Elsey's has a slightly lower concentration of fruits, veggies, grains, and starches.

First 10 ingredients:

duck dried chicken hydrolyzed pork gelatin pork plasma chicken fat ground flaxseed dried pork liver natural flavor salmon oil

 

Carnilove Duck & Turkey

Kibble

View complete details

Dr. Elsey's cleanprotein Duck & Chicken

Kibble

View complete details

 
Score
C
Score
B
Food Type Kibble Kibble
Meat % 70% Unknown
Protein % 37% 58%
Fat % 18% 18%
Fiber % 3% 4%
Protein to Fat Ratio 2.06 to 1 3.22 to 1
Total Ingredients 28 18
Meat Content 6 total
low quality
8 total
high concentration, high quality
Non-Meats 10 total
low concentration
1 total
low concentration
Sugar-free Yes Yes
Controversial ingredient-free Yes Yes
 

Feedback