Lily's Kitchen Smooth Paté for Kittens Chicken vs. Dr. Elsey's cleanprotein Duck & Chicken

cat
This information is for cats.
If you have ferrets, please check out Ferret Love

Create an account to hide ads!

vs

Lily's Kitchen has a better protein to fat ratio. Dr. Elsey's's ratio of 3.22 to 1 is too high (not fatty enough). (The ideal ratio is 2 to 1.) Lily's Kitchen has much fewer ingredients, which is usually a good thing. Both foods are mostly free of fruits, veggies, grains, and starches.

Lily's Kitchen Smooth Paté for Kittens Chicken

Lily's Kitchen has a better protein to fat ratio. Dr. Elsey's's ratio of 3.22 to 1 is too high (not fatty enough). (The ideal ratio is 2 to 1.)
Lily's Kitchen has much fewer ingredients, which is usually a good thing.

Legend

First 10 ingredients:

freshly prepared chicken freshly prepared pork freshly prepared trout freshly prepared beef minerals zinc manganese iodine salmon oil algae

Dr. Elsey's cleanprotein Duck & Chicken

First 10 ingredients:

duck dried chicken hydrolyzed pork gelatin pork plasma chicken fat ground flaxseed dried pork liver natural flavor salmon oil

 

Lily's Kitchen Smooth Paté for Kittens Chicken

Canned

View complete details

Dr. Elsey's cleanprotein Duck & Chicken

Kibble

View complete details

 
Score
A
Score
B
Food Type Canned Kibble
Meat % 65% Unknown
Protein % 10% 58%
Fat % 6% 18%
Fiber % 0.2% 4%
Protein to Fat Ratio 1.67 to 1 3.22 to 1
Total Ingredients 7 18
Meat Content 4 total
high quality
8 total
high concentration, high quality
Non-Meats None 1 total
low concentration
Sugar-free Yes Yes
Controversial ingredient-free Yes Yes
 

Feedback